SimRacing.org.uk

UKGPL => UKGPL Races => Topic started by: G Jonsson on September 17, 2012, 12:59:50 AM +0100



Title: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: G Jonsson on September 17, 2012, 12:59:50 AM +0100
WELCOME TO THE UKGPL SEASON 23 HISTORIC (66) TROPHY

For the fifth round we go to Canada. Mosport Park is allmost straight forward except some "moss", be aware.

There will be full moderation of lap one Red Zone and reported incidents for the rest of the race. Please submit incident reports within a week after the race so that the moderators report may be out before the next race.

The Red Zone is from start to after Moss.

Reserve drivers should not use the server between 35 and 30 minutes of qualifying if it is full, to allow full timers to join.

Please restrict chat to a minimum, (or maybe none).

Do not rely on luck.
 
Race List =         iGOR
Server =            UKGPL_T7_2
IP Address =       62.149.202.168
Race date =       18-09-2012
Time =              Race start 21.30 UK time
Track =             Mosport Park  1967   Canadian Grand Prix
Variant =           66F1 2L engines
Damage Model =  PRO
Qualifying time =  >30 minutes. You are free to start as soon as the server is up but reserve drivers should not use the server between 35 and 30 minutes of qualifying if it is full, to allow full timers to join.
Race length =     Pro Long (36 laps)

The track can be downloaded from:papy track

The cars
Group I
T1F Eagle Climax
Lotus 33 Climax

Group II
Brabham BT11 2.5lt
Lotus 33 BRM


GroupIII
Ferrari 246
Brabham BT11 BRM
BRM P261
Brabham BT11 2.7lt


Drivers Restricted to cars from Group I

Al Heller
EvilClive


Drivers Restricted to cars form Group II or Group I

Dave Rainier


All other drivers have free chassis choice.


Password: see above


(2) Driver lists can be found on the championship standings page







Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: bernie on September 18, 2012, 08:24:59 PM +0100
Dohhh ! faut it wuz silver wiv f2's terneet  :-\


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on September 18, 2012, 09:49:02 PM +0100
Dave, next time you have someone side by side with you, don't just open the line on corner exit like you're alone on the track!


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: vosblod on September 18, 2012, 09:55:30 PM +0100
Surprised myself by getting 5th in Qually as I don't usually run the 66 but when I saw it was Mosport I couldn't resist.
Nice clean start from what I could see, although I saw Paul and Nigel retire early on. Chugging along nicely and watching Evil endeavour to pass ahead (and lend me a nice bit of tow) when his victim took a spin - completely solo and nowt to do with Mr Evil from what I could see.

Anyway I managed to avoid impact but my evasive action sent me spinning and I came to a halt watching the whole pack pass and disappear into the distance.
To be honest after that, and with no championship points at stake for me, I really didn't fancy 30 odd laps of playing with myself - a small step up from watching paint dry.
No one's fault at all but, not being a contender this season, I have the luxury of dipping into whatever tickles my fancy :clown:

Anyway congrats to whoever wins, enjoyed it while it lasted.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Rainier on September 18, 2012, 10:40:40 PM +0100
Dave, next time you have someone side by side with you, don't just open the line on corner exit like you're alone on the track!

Hristo,
Are you sure, it was me ?



Race was fun during the 18 first laps, I think I was 2nd during one lap or two.  Then Phil, Göran, Hristo and Andreas overtook me without any resistance from me because my main objective was to finish the race.

The 18 last laps were boring, I just had to avoid too many mistakes because Bernie was close.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: bernie on September 18, 2012, 10:54:54 PM +0100
Not to worry , Bernie wasn't "that close" , your rear end was quite safe ( on this occasion )  ;D

Pretty boring race for me too , just hung on for the finish , can't seem to get the hang of these 66 machines , maybe a lack of practise ( same for the other mods come to think of it )  ::)


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Phil Thornton on September 18, 2012, 11:08:08 PM +0100
Dave, next time you have someone side by side with you, don't just open the line on corner exit like you're alone on the track!
H, I think you must be referring to me not Dave.  I saw you disappear from my mirrors at the exit of the last turn and so I expected you to be along side over the start line.  As we entered turn 1 I gave you plenty of room because I expected you to try the inside line.  You didn't get through and I caught a brief glimpse of you in my mirrors so I knew you were behind again at that stage.  Although I could hear a car I couldn't see you and given that there were 2 other green cars behind me (3 in total) both flashing in and out of view I wasn't sure where you were.  I kept the inside line for turn 2B just in case you were on the outside.  I was trying to hold onto second place and I wasn't going to give it up without a fight so I accelerated hard out of the corner.  I didn't expect you to try and drive around the outside of me, you must have been trying very hard because you had 2 wheels on the grass on the exit (before we made contact). 

I'll submit an incident report and let the mods decide if I did anything wrong.  I tried my best to race clean but given I hadn't had a clear view of you since the last turn on the previous lap it was hard to know where you were especially with 2 other cars in my mirrors.  As you know passing on the outside is always risky (warp, inside driver spinning - just what happened to me at Spa (https://www.simracing.org.uk/smf/index.php?topic=11031.msg199226#msg199226)) I simply didn't expect you to try such a risky move so early on in the race.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on September 19, 2012, 03:24:40 AM +0100
Sorry, Dave, I thought it was you.

Phil, I was in complete control on the outside line at T2 and accelerated better around the corner because it's easier to do so when you take such a line. I left plenty of room for whoever was on the inside (I couldn't see, but I knew there was a car on the inside and I could hear its engine) and even though I stepped on the grass on the exit, it was only right at the exit of the corner, and I didn't go off with 4 wheels or anything like that. I haven't seen the replay, but from what I saw just a moment before impact, your car took the optimal line and went right next to the edge of the track, instead of maintaining the inside line.

I'll have a look at the replay and submit my point of view to the incident report.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Phil Thornton on September 19, 2012, 02:05:56 PM +0100
Phil, I was in complete control on the outside line at T2 ......
I don't doubt that H, not many drivers could attempt such a pass :).  If I'd known it was you I might have half expected it.  But given I don't use Prib (framerate issues), my Pit Board said Rainier and you were on pole and should have been miles ahead, how could I know?

Anyway, nothing personal I'm sure the mods will be fair.  Regardless of the outcome I still think you would have been better waiting for one more corner before making a move.  I would have taken my normal line and you would of had the opportunity to make an easy pass up the inside into T3.

Good luck in the next race.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on September 19, 2012, 08:41:21 PM +0100
Phil, the problem is I was quite slow on the straights, as my gearbox was not really set up very well, so my only chances was to push into the corners. I also thought it was Rainier because of my pitboard (LOL, I guess he was on everyone's pitboard?!), and I felt I was already slightly ahead before the exit of the corner, so there was no reason not to attempt the pass. Anyway, it happens.

Grats to Clive for the win! It seems I've dropped out of contention for the championship now, but I'll try help the team win the constructors title and support Evil in his battle.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Phil Thornton on September 19, 2012, 09:59:13 PM +0100
.....so there was no reason not to attempt the pass.
You were entitled to attempt the pass and you didn't cause the collision, I did.  I moved over and as such I'm probably guilty of a Simple Side-by-Side (scenario 4 see here (https://www.ukgpl.com/index.php/rules/side_by_side)) and I'm likely to get a 1 place penalty (I knew that when I reported the incident, I don't only report incidents where I think I am the innocent party).  But that would only drop me back to third; the best I could have hoped for if you'd got past cleanly and chased after Evil.  The mods might even decide there were mitigating factors and conclude it was a contested pass in which case I wouldn't be penalised at all.  It is up to them, I'll accept whatever decision they come to. 

Whatever the outcome it doesn't alter the fact that you can't be reinstated and it seems you think you are out of the championship chase which is a pity.  I appreciate in this case being hampered by a slow car means you have to make the most of every chance you get but if you can avoid being taken out and finish the rest of the races I'm sure you could still win this championship (Evil has to drop 2 scores don't forget).


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: BadBlood on January 11, 2013, 10:15:19 AM +0000
Mod published. Sorry for the delay.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on January 11, 2013, 11:01:03 AM +0000
Mod published. Sorry for the delay.

Took me a few seconds to recall what this is about, lol. Not that I want to blame Phil for anything, he actually apologized if I remember and it was quite a heated moment at the time so I understand where he was coming from (which is why I didn't report it), but you can't say there was no room for 2 cars. The track is wide enough for even more than 2, and having seen me disappear into his blind spot earlier, it makes sense that I was still side by side by the corner exit and he should have kept his line. It was an avoidable incident, but I guess we all try to learn from our mistakes.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: BadBlood on January 11, 2013, 01:51:11 PM +0000
Not enough room if the inside car takes the racing line...

It was avoidable but also understandable which is why it ended up being Neutral. I don't think Phil needs me to teach him how to drive ;)


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on January 11, 2013, 11:18:17 PM +0000
Not enough room if the inside car takes the racing line...

That's the point though, the car on the inside should not use the racing line when they have someone on the outside in their blind spot and then use the "not enough room" as an excuse. Just trying to make sure such kind of incidents are moderated better in the future.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: BadBlood on January 13, 2013, 11:55:55 PM +0000
LOL. I took the view that Phil was reasonable to assume that he had a lead (if slightly dozy) but there was no question of culpability on your part H. I am not sure anyone else would try a pass there though... it's hard enough to carry the speed on the line...


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on January 14, 2013, 12:17:30 AM +0000
LOL. I took the view that Phil was reasonable to assume that he had a lead (if slightly dozy) but there was no question of culpability on your part H. I am not sure anyone else would try a pass there though... it's hard enough to carry the speed on the line...

Sure, but if you are in the lead, you are most certain to see at least parts of the other car in your mirrors, not to mention the way the engine sound from the other car is delivered. My point is, unless you're almost 100% sure you have nobody on your side, it's a big risk to change lines. You know about the similar incident with myself and Nathan in the F2 Hockenheim race, the one I appealed for.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: BadBlood on January 14, 2013, 09:04:49 AM +0000
I don't think that was quite the same. You never appear in Phil's mirrors and engine note is impossible to tell apart from the other cars because they are so close. I think Phil would acknowledge that he could have been more helpful. I don't think he changed line so much as committed to the racing line which is where the incidents differ IMHO. But, of course, that is only my opinion. Anyway, I take the point!


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: Hristo Itchov on January 14, 2013, 10:13:14 PM +0000
I don't think that was quite the same. You never appear in Phil's mirrors and engine note is impossible to tell apart from the other cars because they are so close. I think Phil would acknowledge that he could have been more helpful. I don't think he changed line so much as committed to the racing line which is where the incidents differ IMHO. But, of course, that is only my opinion. Anyway, I take the point!

I think I was in Phil's mirrors a corner or two ago? Surely I must have been behind at some point before making a move, lol. Some incidents should be rewind back a bit in the replay before passing judgement. Also, the similarity between the incidents is that both cars on the inside used the racing line and went towards the outside at corner exit.


Title: Re: UKGPL Season 23 (2012) Historic Trophy (66) - Mosport - Sep 18
Post by: BadBlood on January 15, 2013, 01:06:46 AM +0000
LOL 'Nuff said