SimRacing.org.uk

Race Room Experience => RRE => Topic started by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 11:17:42 AM +0000



Title: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 11:17:42 AM +0000
I am hoping to run some series again next year, even thought the turn out is low, when people do come along
we usually have a good time  ;D

I will run an NSU series again, as that gives some serious fun.
What else would people (those that there are...) like to see, before I just go and do the usual?
I would like to keep it historic ish, but I am open to anything that might be a success
F1 style? other single seat options, excepting the Formula junior, as Tudor already has plans for those.
Aquila? Hillclimb specials? DTM92? Touring Classics? (perhaps without the Nissan), One of the Audi SPorts versions?
I liked the Silhouette series, not sure if Tudor is doing thos again next year?
seriously, anything is under consideration. If we had 20 members all coming along for the Historic events
I would think different, but we haven't. SO gimme some thoughs please  :chef:


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: Wiltshire Tony on December 16, 2016, 11:20:19 AM +0000
Matt, I'd like to assign E4 to any RRE 2017 series please. I have already done this for Goldtop's series.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 11:30:59 AM +0000
Thanks Tony. There will be an E4NSU, other than that, don't know yet.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 12:25:03 PM +0000
Just done a few laps in a KTM Crossbow at Sonoma. These feel just like a race car should
They handle well, they turn in well, perhaps too well, and they have enough power
to get up to a decent speed. I like these  :)


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: frex on December 16, 2016, 12:52:27 PM +0000
I would be quite happy just doing more of the same again, maybe with more limited car choices in some cases if one or other car is considered too far ahead of the rest. Also happy to consider the Silhouettes again, and the Hillclimb Icons too, although never tried those.

One thing I wouldn't mind trying for a change is something FWD - I'm not normally a fan, but in pCARS there is a brilliant little Renault Clio series which is great fun; anything similar in RRE?

EDIT: The WTCC 2013 pack looks promising, with 4 FWD cars vs 1 RWD, and quite cheap too - 545 vrp for all 5 cars and lots of liveries (before any potential Christmas sale discounts). Anyone tried these?


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 12:57:44 PM +0000
Hmm, good thought. Some of the WTCC cars - Citroen/Chevvy are FWD i guess they will be like Race07
which was my fave sim of all time. I will give one or two a roll.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: goldtop on December 16, 2016, 01:29:34 PM +0000
The WTCC 2013 pack looks promising, with 4 FWD cars vs 1 RWD, and quite cheap too - 545 vrp for all 5 cars and lots of liveries (before any potential Christmas sale discounts). Anyone tried these?

Good call Dieter! I have a few of the WTCC 2013 cars along with the later years and they are all good fun. As you say, the 2013 pack has the RWD BMW which might appease those who don't enjoy FWD. As for Race07, the Raceroom WTCC cars are a waaaaaaay better drive imho.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 16, 2016, 02:10:16 PM +0000
Well I just tried a selection of the WTCC 13/14 and 15 cars, and I may be missing something
because to me they are nothing like as good as the Race07 cars.

The Beemer in the 2013 is a bit wet to me, but is ok, all of the FWD cars have the most unrealistic
lift off oversteer like the rears are on Dunlop Groundhogs, which makes them a questionable choice.
You can get rid of it by setting the front everything max hard, and the rear everything max soft, and full rear wing
but they still want to wander off track with the slightest lift.
I set one as above, and the corner entry was not too bad, but the inside front was wheelspinning like crazy
I get similar times with 2013 and 2015 cars, the beemer was 0.5 secs slower round Sonoma sprint
btu I did less laps in him, as he seemed fairly "normal"

I like the idea, and could race these, but It would need a few people asking for them.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: goldtop on December 16, 2016, 02:23:25 PM +0000
BTW Sunday series for 2017 (up to July) is as follows:

GT3 Sprint
GT3 Endurance
DTM 2016
Formula Raceroom Junior

I'd be happy to race pretty much anything on Thursdays apart from maybe the quicker open wheelers and the KTM which just feels a bit strange to me  :-\


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: SRW on December 17, 2016, 10:09:54 AM +0000
I would be interested in racing a FWD WTCC. I have spent most of my adulthood driving round like a boy racer in FWD in real life (as I suspect most of us sim racers have) so would be good to compare the game to real life (even though the closest to a racing car I have ever owned was an Astra GTE 16v).
I also liked racing the silouettes in Goldtops series.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: Wiltshire Tony on December 17, 2016, 11:38:08 AM +0000
Details of Goldtop's forthcoming Sunday series found here https://www.simracing.org.uk/smf/index.php?action=LM2R&group=577&theme=4


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 17, 2016, 11:57:19 AM +0000
We can run a WTCC series if people want it no prob. WOuld be nice if a few did a road test before
I ask Tony to create the series.
I still like the KTM, it just feels superb to me. But I am not going to run a series if there is only me that likes them.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: goldtop on December 17, 2016, 12:17:45 PM +0000
We can run a WTCC series if people want it no prob. WOuld be nice if a few did a road test before
I ask Tony to create the series.
I still like the KTM, it just feels superb to me. But I am not going to run a series if there is only me that likes them.

Just gave the KTM another go and discovered my steering settings were all over the place which explains the weird feeling I was having......all good now.

It should be possible to create a RL WTCC series as I believe all the tracks are there  ;)


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: Eck Simpson on December 17, 2016, 01:52:05 PM +0000
If it is decided that a WTCC series is a good idea, I'd prefer the newer/est cars. I'm useless in them but I do enjoy the newer cars, most.

I like the KTM too, though I've not tried racing them yet.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 17, 2016, 02:06:03 PM +0000
I really like the KTM, though someone has said they hated them? perhaps that was in AC?
I have done some more testing with the WTCC cars, this time at Zandvoort GP
I can do high 1:47/low 1:48 in any of the 2013 cars, and the 2014/15 cars are about
4 or more seconds faster. I was hoping to run the later cars but include the Beemer from the 2013 set
to give people an option, but the Beemer is about 4 or 5 secs slower than the 2015 cars so that won't work
so I would suggest WTCC 2013 as the staple, with perhaps an occasional event with 2015 cars.
I would be open to running the Sillouette cars, but I don't really want 5 series.

My current thinking is 4 series:

WTCC2013 (2015)
KTM Crossbow
DTM92/Touring Classics, with occasional "Guest" car set - Procar/GTO/Gr5
NSU TTS

How does this feel?



Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: goldtop on December 17, 2016, 03:22:03 PM +0000
Sounds good to me  :thumbup1:


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: spanner on December 17, 2016, 06:03:40 PM +0000
I'm wary of FWD, as i really struggle to drive with that much understeer.

Its a shame that most of the content is either GTR3, DTM or WTCC cars to provide a good variety. We are going to end up repeating a bit.

Not tried the KTM yet.



Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: Hotkeys on December 18, 2016, 08:45:50 AM +0000
Sounds good to me  :thumbup1:

I agree

Stig


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 18, 2016, 12:05:16 PM +0000
Agreed Mark. Those were the best options I could think of from what there is.
I would like some P&G/GTL type cars, and more historic tracks, like Imola, Goodwood
Watkins Glen etc, but they don't exist. I wonder if there are to be any more tracks?
I don't follow the forums, so don't know what's in the pipe.

Tony, when you get a minute (or 30) please could you create the 4 series? as I am not privileged enough somehow?

E4NSU (already done, thanks)
E4KTM
E4T
E4WTCC


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: frex on December 18, 2016, 12:16:54 PM +0000
all of the FWD cars have the most unrealistic
lift off oversteer like the rears are on Dunlop Groundhogs

But that's what makes them fun..! And quite honestly doesn't feel all that unrealistic to me - lift-off oversteer is the dominant handling trait in any track prepared FWD car surely?

I don't have any of these cars yet, but took a few for a test drive (with locked-in default setup unfortunately) and actually preferred the 2013 cars; the newer cars seem to be scrabbling for grip a lot more, probably because they have a bit more power. If I could change the setup however, I suspect I might improve things. The 2013 set also has the RWD option for those that want it, and is cheaper, so a good choice imho.

I hopped into the KTM too, but couldn't get on with that in my brief test drive. Again, maybe because I could not access the setup options, but it felt a bit odd to me. Still happy to give it a go though.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 18, 2016, 12:24:03 PM +0000
I have got the WTCC cars to be drivable (for me) by raising the rear wing, making the front only slightly softer than the rear settings
from the very soft front very hard rear, and I found reducing coast diff helped too.
Here is a little vid of me in a short wheelbase FWD car with a good helping of lift off oversteer in T3 at Anglesey a few years ago

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dl3PzuapURM

I have had years of sprinting track prepared FWD cars, so I have some idea of what is realistic. I have never driven
anything like these proper racing long wheelbase WTCC cars, so they will be more front grippy, but it just doesn't
feel realistic to me with the default settings.


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: spanner on December 18, 2016, 07:04:44 PM +0000
Eek that KTM is a bit raw! main issue is going to be the braking.

Id be happier if we were doing the 2013 carset for the beemer. tried out the 2015 cars which i bought round zandvoort. Shocked at how different racing fwd cars are to road cars. requires a how different techniqe and racing line. Not sure i'll enjoy them but will try and put up with them!


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: phspok on December 18, 2016, 11:36:25 PM +0000
Raw? I must give it another go, to me it felt very well behaved, though the turn it was a bit sharp
it didn't want to spin anything like as much as the WTCC cars, which seem to have loads of front grip
and the rear is on 145x65x15 crossply tyres


Title: Re: R3E 2017
Post by: spanner on December 20, 2016, 09:30:49 PM +0000
I know its not been mentioned but thought i'd share my thoughts.

Was expecting the TT RS thingy to be the worst FWD car ever. Its actually one of the best cars there, you really wouldnt know it was fwd around the test track. Its got so much grip as well.


Just tried the DTM2016 competion at Nurburgring. These things are a bit edgy. they are very stiff and lots of aero, keep it under control and they feel a little unrealistic in there cornering speed. Not easy to catch if you get it wrong.

Tried out the FR3 as well, nice little car but doesnt slide well!

Need to assk on the forum as the incar cam movement is so rubbish, it just bounces up and down. Surely you can get it move more realistically, look int othe turn, show G effects etc..