I know many people like ARCA, and I've tried it. I just don't think it compares very well to driving a car at all. The car feels just too dead, as it doesn't react much to anything. You can race door to door in NR2003 too, but that requires all drivers to get broadband instead of 56k modem, and a couple of settings changes. The problem is that NR2003 is by default set up for a 56k modem.
NR2003 demo can be found here:
http://www.gamershell.com/news_5748.htmlI think it's fine that many people prefer ARCA, I don't have a problem with that, I just think it's important to get the other opinions out as well. And there's not many drivers in my league that likes ARCA. I think it's very easy to be led by the majority, to think it's either good or bad, so it's always a good idea to try for yourself. And always remember the first impression isn't always the best one.