The Spirit of British SimRacing   

Read this first!    
 
April 27, 2024, 05:08:26 AM +0100 *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
Series
Recent
Forthcoming
News: Upcoming Events are as follows: 1 - RRE/AC/ACC Sunday - No event ; 2 - GTL Monday - No event 3 - AC Wed - No event 4 - RRE Thursday - No event

RACE SERIES KEY A19=Assetto Corsa, E10=Raceroom Experience, L23=UKGTL GT Legends, LN2=Legacy NoGrip GT Legends, LNE1=Legacy NoGrip GT Legends Endurance races
 
  Start Here      Home   Help Search Calendar Login Register     LM2 Replays Rules Links Circuits Teams  
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
  Print  
Author Topic: GTR Evolution..a way forward?  (Read 17879 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Mark J
Incident Moderators
Hero Member
****
Posts: 10378


Legend in his own lunchtime


View Profile
« on: October 28, 2010, 09:04:23 PM +0100 »

Heres a curve ball for you all to chew on.  Smiley With all the recent chat about declining grids, sprucing up our current GT leagues, add on cars etc, there is one thing we havent considered and thats perhaps buying GTR evolution and using that for our GT racing series. It comes with 49 car variants including some very tasty GT cars in different classes including all the cars we are talking about adding to our current stable of cars. Its 2 years further down the line in terms of car and simracing development than GTR2. It allegedly has a superior physics and gfx engine and apparently was highly approved by many current 'real world' race drivers who tried it out.

The game can be bought for a measly £10 nowadays making it a bargain and i intend to buy it to use for my own pleasure at that price. Scanning the web revealed some very tasty mods are available for it, such as FIA GT 2010 car pack ! Porsche supercup, F430v997 mod, F1 2008 etc etc. Sounds great to me, anyone else interested? Pretty sure most of us that race regularly would be happy to spend a tenner to get such a huge update in cars, gfx, physics, grip and the rest  Cool  I think at the time we overlooked this sim as we had our hands full of GTR2 and GTL and this new sim had lost the FIA license...heck it didnt even have a porsche in it!  Shocked  But i think its time to re-evaluate its potential to us. What say ye?

Also here are some snippets from independant sim racing reviews:-

"Deep in the World Wide Interweb exists a riveting head-to-head video showdown pertinent to any critique of SimBin's latest racing-simulation opus, GTR Evolution. In the center of the screen: in-car footage of noted real-world driver HJ Stuck as he picks his way through the 13-mile (!), 80-plus-turn hell of Germany's infamous and oh-so-deadly Nürburgring Nordschleife. Surrounding the Stuck video: a saved replay of noted sim racer Markus Möller doing precisely the same thing while navigating Evolution's virtual depiction of the very same circuit. To say the two versions look almost indistinguishable is compliment enough to the SimBin development team. But that only tells part of the story.

To drive the monstrous Nordschleife -- to reallydrive it, until you no longer feel like a stranger -- is to experience the current pinnacle of race simology. The Evolution physics model, a carefully calculated blend of realism and challenge that never feels artificially difficult, really gets to show its stuff on this, arguably the most frightening and certainly the most sinewy and lengthy of all racing venues. That the GTR series now features not only Nordschleife but 19 other tracks from across the globe, a stunning 49 unique vehicles divided into 12 separate classes, and compelling new perks such as dynamic weather (a sunny day can quickly devolve into a blinding rainstorm) is awesome news for any driver. But that doesn't tell the whole story, either.

Simply, Evolution transports you from your computer desk and into the cockpit -- I can't think of any other way to say it. Indeed, it may not even be the superb physics or SimBin's delicious visuals that first grab you. It may instead be the sound -- an audio culmination of sorts from SimBin's previous titles that leaves no noise unturned. Rain bouncing off your roof and splattering on your windshield, dislodged gravel popping up against your undercarriage, the multilevel protestation of your tortured motor, the complex howls of overstressed brakes and tires. It may even be the physical sensation of what surely must be the finest, most varied, and most accurate force-feedback coding of any racing game.

One thing's certain: When you dive deep into a corner, hearing everything you should hear, seeing everything you should see, and feeling everything you should feel, you will be in sim nirvana. That GTR's A.I. drivers have flung aside past indiscretions and now exhibit seemingly human smarts and collision avoidance only adds to the fun.

Is Evolution leaps and bounds ahead of prior editions of the series? No. Instead, it tidies up loose ends, perfects what needed perfecting, and delivers more cars than most of us will ever use -- including several credible "concept" vehicles that exist only within the game. It also offers up a purely arcade mode to help sim newbies through the transition to the real world. And, as has always been the case in the GTR series, Evolution offers a ridiculous number of options and racing variables.

Engine Notes
Sound effects in a game can make or break even the biggest title games, your eyes can be fooled into thinking something is real based on the games ability to make you feel like your actually in the race car driving the laps. I find we are much more sensitive to sound effects which don't sound appropriate for the car. GTR Evolution though felt like an aural ecstasy of polished off engine sounds straight from the Ferrari factory in Maranello. The cars in GTR Evolution sound enraged, as they should with 600hp under the bonnet and a minimal 900kg of weight.

Controls
So far we have a game that looks stunning graphically, sounds great with very individual sound effects and a physics engine that hits the bulls eye for this genre. What about the most crucial aspect to un tapping these previously mentioned qualities, controls are the biggest influence on how you interact to a game, luckily though SimBin Did an awesome job, I had my G25 plugged and not only did the GTR Evolution Control menu automatically profile the G25, but gave me the option to pick if I wanted Stick or Paddle shift, The rest of the settings were done for me.

I would have to admit that the force feedback in this game has to be some of the best i've seen yet, why you might ask does this game differentiate so much from other games? When I hold the wheel I feel like i'm holding the wheel, for a game that doesn't use laser scanning of real race tracks the feedback received to me from my G25 come very strong and precise, i've been able to feel certain bumps in the road which would have otherwise lead me to more under steer if the wheel had not responded accordingly. Its these small bits of attention that bring this game above so many in its class."

Also:-
Brief Review of GTR Evolution (for the GTR2 Crowd)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I figured that this forum was a better place for this review, insofar that I am hoping to peak the interest of those on the fence or happily on one side of it . I will discuss Grip, Race Competion, Content (cars and tracks), and Presentation (sounds, gfx, etc.).

First off lets talk about grip. I loved GTL, but the "grip" of the cars always felt very detached. I felt as though I was learning how to play the game more than I was learning to race faster. Obviously good driving technique was essential, but I always felt as though the "feel" and the "grip" were detached and unrealistically sensitive. I couldn't dial in where the limit was until the car slid off the track or spun.

GTR2 improved the road "feel" a great deal, and it was possible to push the cars and discover the limits from your feel of the grip of the tires on the road and the shifting load of the suspension. The game felt less about "memorizing" how to drive and more about developing a masterful driving technique and practice regimine for discoverng what was within the car's limits. Despite driving some of the best engineered cars in the world, cars that have been stripped of all comfort and unnesessary weight and fitted with the finest kit, I felt as though there was still a detached feeling of the car from the track. Even in GTR2 I felt as though it was not so much my adaptave driving technique and feel for grip that produced good times, but rather a mastery of the game mechanics.

Now I know many here disagree, but I found that Race'07 improved the realistic feel of the road and the grip was more appropriate for these race-purpose cars. Race'07 was the first game where I could discover the limits of a car on a track with a great level of feedback. Where as in GTL and GTR2 the grip felt as though it was On/Off, Race'07 had varying degrees. Obviously if you make a serious error you will spin, slide and just generally drastically lose control. But if you are dancing on the razor's edge of grip you can feel it.

A lot of sim racers criticise Race'07 as too grippy and correspondingly label it closer to arcade than sim, but I feel as though this is incorrect. GTR2 fans are used to a more dramatic break in grip when they push near the limit. But this is not realistic. When you are pushing the limit (i.e. not severely jumping over and beyond it) in a car you know it, your grip begins to fade and the car begins to unsetle. The car doesn't break immediately. When you watch racing you can see how drivers make corrections in a turn as they push the limits of their cars. If you have had the opportunity to enjoy a track day you know this as well. If you have ever had the fortune to race Karts or even drive a pure track purpose car, you are indeed familiar with the common racing skill of feeling the limits of grip and suspension and making corrections. Race'07 provides this feedback, and because race sim fans have for years become familiar with a game model that is more abrupt with grip I think they are quick to accuse the Race'07 game model as unrealistic.

GTR Evo ("Evo") has all the physics of Race '07. The "arcade extreme" is an entirely seperate game mode that you can gladly ignore and never even go near. The driving feel that the physics of Evo gives you, allows the skilled and practiced driver to race on the edge and find grip or push the limits of the car outside the memorized race line, which makes for some excellent racing and undoubetly a big fat smile on your face when you overtake a driver in a paintswapping battle royale!

I have been racing online for four years, and the best racing I have ever experienced has been in Race'07. The game has allowed me to be more confident in tight racing, in being able to push the car outsde of my practiced lines, and in knowing that my opponents have the same feel of the road. Nearly every race between equal opponents is a paintswapping battle that pushes nerves and stamina to the limit. Evo maintains this fantastic feeling (and I have indeed enjoyed some great WTCC class races...3 wide racing, 10 laps and 4 drivers within 1 second at the end!) but kicks it up a notch with several new classes of car that force you to race diferently around the track.

Its a fantastic feeling to balance a big GT car along the rolling hills of Zandervoort, clawing for grip, as you steady the wheel and bury the throttle into a series of right handers that take just as much balls as brakes to handle. Don't worry about your fillings that shook lose, you can get them recapped later .

The balance between the classes is phenominal. No single supercar that is just better. The cars in the classes have their own distict handling and performance traits, but can all stay up each others' tailpipe around the tracks. You like the big musle rumble and stiff Saleen over the howling and nimble Aston pick it and you can drive your style and still win. If you favor the all around go-getter from Belgium with a Detroit heart of gold, jump in a Spyker and take on a friend driving the M3 that must be wresteled into submission for the best times or the Toledo which favors the pocket protector wearing driver who takes his turns with razor sharp precision.

Since the physics of Evo lets you really "feel" the car's weight, you will really enjoy swapping between the big fuel guzzling GT pro beasts and the light nimble GT sports. The big A8GT may dominate at Curbitia, but the little Z4M might just turn some heads at Brands Hatch Indy!

I have hinted as to some of the content, and you can read all you like online. The WTCC tracks are great. There is a great amount of detail in the undulations, bumps, and offcamber turns. When Race '07 was released they had every WTCC driver playing it and giving the track designs a thumbs up. You can always toss in your old faves! I sure as rain have Spa '64, '03 and '04 amoung others. Evo even seperates your add-on tracks under a seperate button for easy access. Of course you have the "Ring", I don't think I need to elaborate on that.

Each class of car makes for a different race. The WTCCs are slower, but high center of gravity on big body cars with slicks makes for some exciting racing after 8 laps...and its always CLOSE!!! FWD also is a whole new beast to master in the turns. The F3000 cars will blow your mind with the speeds at which they can stick to the track after the tires heat up. Minis are a trip, and low horsepower means little mistakes won't leave you in the dust, and neither will some hard petting . GTs are just orgasmically awesome. Though for all those who thought Race '07 was too easy...OH MAMA these GTs are a handful! The production classes are for those who like to ride with the rear end wide, but don't like their overalls dirty and their eardrums bleading...we'll see those drivers at the club later for bubly and caviar.

So lets see, we have the best physics to date in a race sim to keep you running timmed laps all night; we have awesome racing to keep a big smile on your face and the bragging rights in constant flow; and we have enough auto porn to keep you...ahem...excited. Well if that's not enough then how about the best ISI sound and graphics.

Firstly the sound is a work of art. The Saleen just sounds orgasmic...I had to get that out. But the complexity and quality is all there for once. The brakes, the transmission whine, and the engine, it all there and its all unique to each car, and its all great. The crowd is in on it too, with cheering and air hornes. Crashes sound damaging, and gravel sounds like its getting all up in your car's naughty bits.

The graphics look fantastic and run super smooth on my three year old system (cept for last year's 8800GT).

Menues are smooth and well organized, FFB is solid, and you can tune in your control sensitivity at speed and tune in amplitude adjustments, which is good for the twitchy driver or gamepad user.



Logged

Truetom
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 5227

Ljubljana, Slovenia


View Profile
« Reply #1 on: October 28, 2010, 09:15:22 PM +0100 »

Dedication, I see. Would like to hear more GTR2 guys and will then decide. Not turning away, not jumping in. Smiley
Logged
Mark J
Incident Moderators
Hero Member
****
Posts: 10378


Legend in his own lunchtime


View Profile
« Reply #2 on: October 28, 2010, 09:19:48 PM +0100 »

nicely sat on the fence TT  Wink  Cheesy

here is the video referred to in above review:-

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXlr52Cp_Uo

wow!...and we all thought IR had the take on surveying tracks. These are identical in the real footage and evo version  Shocked

ps..i just ordered my copy of it  Smiley

promo vid:-  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwkYBTP67I0
« Last Edit: October 28, 2010, 09:23:59 PM +0100 by Mark J » Logged

goldtop
Director, RRE
SimRacing.org.uk Staff
Hero Member
****
Posts: 4319


Team KC


View Profile
« Reply #3 on: October 28, 2010, 09:30:06 PM +0100 »

And don't forget Race 07 is also included in the Evo package, so potentially you'll be able to join us on Wednesdays  Cool

Logged

TOP TIP: READ THE RACE ANNOUNCEMENT Smiley
nsfast
Full Member
***
Posts: 287


View Profile
« Reply #4 on: October 28, 2010, 09:47:52 PM +0100 »

The GT cars in GTR Evo have never felt quite right to me. But maybe thats because I've only ever used the default setups. However, having experienced how good the Caterhams can be, perhaps it may be worth having a another look at GTR Evo.  Huh

£10 for this sim is certainly a bargain.  Smiley
« Last Edit: October 28, 2010, 09:51:07 PM +0100 by nsfast » Logged
spanner
Director, AC
SimRacing.org.uk Staff
Hero Member
****
Posts: 6106


Team Prodigy - UKGTR/UKAC


View Profile
« Reply #5 on: October 28, 2010, 09:50:12 PM +0100 »

Plus Race doesnt handle pitting well, with no damage repair. WTCC cars dont pit so they never built it quite as well as GTR2
Logged

Learn to love the Pork Smiley

Team Prodigy - Just like Team Oldie only younger, faster, less grey hair and kinder to the environment!
pribeiro
Full Member
***
Posts: 1420


Animals and racing lover


View Profile
« Reply #6 on: October 28, 2010, 09:50:46 PM +0100 »

I always said that about GTREVO Mark Roll Eyes  
It's a nice and better game in all ways than GTR2, period.  Kiss
Logged

Isn't my avatar amazingly sweet?
ginsters sponsored
Grey Leader
Former Moderators
Sr. Member
**
Posts: 3234


View Profile WWW
« Reply #7 on: October 28, 2010, 09:53:13 PM +0100 »

I've got it but never had the time to tinker with it Smiley I was surprised how many were on servers recently so it must have something. Be up for using it now.

However, its adoption really isn't gonna solve the iR conundrum that has split this league. Those happy in iR land just aren't gonna use it, or they would argue go back to it. So we are still left with two camps in a smallish community which is the root of the problem.

You could argue that this would bring in new punters, as has been suggested with the use of GTR2 mods. But, for me, it will not. Those that wanted to race Evo have already joined leagues elsewhere and we'd be so far behind other leagues in terms of experience and tinker time that we'd hold no real draw. The same applies to the use of GTR2 mods here.

Sorry to appear downcast about Evo and GTR2 which is still my fave but we are were we are with them. For me, the future here is concentrating on developing a niche in iR and drawing punters that way. Its too late for GTR2 here now :'( And maybe Evo?
« Last Edit: October 28, 2010, 09:56:24 PM +0100 by ginsters sponsored » Logged

Legzy
Old Leader
Former Moderators
Hero Member
**
Posts: 5122


Bring back GTR2!


View Profile
« Reply #8 on: October 28, 2010, 10:02:22 PM +0100 »

I have Evo but have only driven the one car & that's the Race'07 Cat.
I couldn't complement the cat enough. Cool
Logged

 Team Oldie   Powered by Viagra!
Adam Parle
Guest
« Reply #9 on: October 29, 2010, 08:57:25 AM +0100 »

I'd say Ginsters has hit the nail on the head - you can't keep trying to play catchup with mods and/or more recent titles.

I think everyone is getting frustrated with the grid sizes we're getting these days in comparison to a couple of years ago when we were running simultaneous 20 car grids on a Sunday night in the "glory days" of GTR2.

We simply don't have the numbers to support the variety of titles currently in use on here imho.   Obviously as one of the iRacing crowd, I'd love to see that take top billing, although I did love the time I had with GTR2 - but something has to be done.
Logged
Simon Gymer
Former Moderators
Hero Member
**
Posts: 9021

Cool Bite


View Profile WWW
« Reply #10 on: October 29, 2010, 09:41:18 AM +0100 »

I thought the reason RACE07/GTR Evo/RACE ON never took off here was that they all felt like a step backwards on GTR2 (in terms of, well, pretty much everything but the net-code)?
Logged

Intel I7-4790K @ 4.0Ghz
MSI NVidia 2080 Ti Gaming X TRIO
16GB DDR3 2400Mhz
3x 1920x1080 27" monitors
Thrustmaster T300GTE Wheel + T3PA Pro Pedals
ginsters sponsored
Grey Leader
Former Moderators
Sr. Member
**
Posts: 3234


View Profile WWW
« Reply #11 on: October 29, 2010, 11:03:40 AM +0100 »

Obviously as one of the iRacing crowd, I'd love to see that take top billing, although I did love the time I had with GTR2 - but something has to be done.

I'm not one of the iR crowd but, for me, thats the only way forward for this place. We've slipped behind other GTR leagues and missed the boat. Time to move on before we miss the iR boat as well (don't think the same applies to PnG and GTL mind).

With all of your focus on iR I'm sure this league will have a rosier future. I'll not be in it but when we all turn to RF2, I'll be back Smiley
Logged

popabawa
Legendary Leader
Former Moderators
Hero Member
**
Posts: 4939


Less yapping and more lapping!


View Profile
« Reply #12 on: October 29, 2010, 11:17:52 AM +0100 »

Unfortunately it's not quite as easy as "focus on iRacing".

I suspect that we're not going to get any more crossover of SRouk drivers to iRacing from GTR/GTL/PnG, no matter how much more iRacing improves (and it has come a long way in the last 2 years).

So, that means recruiting from outside SRouk and that's been pretty spectacularly unsuccessful so far.

I'd love it if we could go muticlass endurance with iRacing but it's difficult to justify given the grid sizes we're getting. Enough for single class, yes (ish), but we'd need another 10+ regulars to go multiclass.

Feels like there's a lot of potential for iRacing fun going wasted Sad
Logged

Legends Racing simracing team
Mark J
Incident Moderators
Hero Member
****
Posts: 10378


Legend in his own lunchtime


View Profile
« Reply #13 on: October 29, 2010, 06:34:01 PM +0100 »

think a few may be missing my point a little when suggesting using evo  Undecided, i wasnt implying that we should use Evo to lure any IR racers away or that we should treat it as the new best thing, it was more a case of 'hang on a minute, we are talking about possibly adding new cars/mods etc to try and liven up GTR2 which is now 4+? years old' when there is a ready made natural evolution of it with a great range of cars, improved physics, gfx,sounds, netcode etc all packaged up nicely in a newer sim that can be picked up for peanuts now.  Smiley

Also, not sure why a few are stating that this should be only an IR race website now? Plenty of us GT and historics racers still lurking, just not getting together for racing for some reason (same as IR it seems), all we see in any series is less than 20 drivers  Sad. Some faces drift in and out, but for some reason they are not staying around to fight in the championships, which seems to prove we arent engaging enough or offering enough  Undecided Perhaps they are prefering other sites series where they have some nice frills like live timing or more cars etc ?  Some of our cars are a tad on the crude/limited side too when you see what mods other sites are using, as we havent updated any since we first got hold of some of the add-ons.

The recent gang of 'Race' users seem to be matching the regular champs for attendance so there must be some legs in it, and Evolution encompasses that sim as well as improving upon it.

Anyhoo, getting evolution onboard here is just a suggestion, and a good one i think, as its fresh and has a lot to offer choice wise.
Ive ordered it anyway, so will enjoy here or elsewhere  Smiley

And listen to the sounds in it....  Cool
DBR9 at Nords in heavy rain
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdMBIGa866Y
Logged

Mark J
Incident Moderators
Hero Member
****
Posts: 10378


Legend in his own lunchtime


View Profile
« Reply #14 on: October 30, 2010, 10:21:47 AM +0100 »

sounds like a few of you already have GTR evo? maybe we can do some trial races to test some cars out when mine arrives  Smiley our reports may convince a few of the fence sitters to dive in. Ive heard the sounds from a few of the GT cars now and boy do they sound the part!...seems Simbin did listen to some of their critism from the online crowd  Smiley
I see it has improved dynamic weather too.  Cool
Logged

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Hosted by DaveGymer.com
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.23 seconds with 24 queries.
anything